Market Update: We break down the business implications, market impact, and expert insights related to Market Update: Businesses may leave WA, but focus should be growing economy – Full Analysis.
Monica’s Waterfront Bakery in Silverdale now Old Town Kitchen
The former Monica’s Waterfront Bakery in Silverdale is going through a transition. Here’s an early look at updates coming to the menu, space and more.
Our recent survey of Washington employers hit a nerve. The results showing that 44% of business leaders are considering moving their personal residence to another state — and the number who are looking to relocate their business has nearly doubled in the last year — made headlines throughout Washington and even across the country.
It’s easy to see why. It’s a shocking number. Nearly half of Washington business leaders might move their personal residence to another state? Really?
For beleaguered business owners who have been hit with billions in new taxes over the last few years, this wasn’t really news, startling as it may seem. The frustration with Washington’s tax and regulatory climate has been steadily building. Many small business owners who saw the news reports may have thought, “yeah, that checks out.”
But for legislators who are trying to pass a bill to bring an income tax to Washington, it was an inconvenient distraction as reporters drew the connection between declining business sentiment and the push for yet another new tax.
In their public comments about the survey, some lawmakers acknowledged that Washington should take the threat of business relocation seriously as they consider tax policy. But some also questioned whether the threat is real, suggesting that businesses won’t really leave and noting that many of the states that business owners might move to already have an income tax.
It’s true, many of the states that Washington business leaders are reportedly eying for relocation (Arizona, Idaho and Montana) have an income tax. For employers, it’s not simply a question of whether a state has an income tax or not — they are evaluating the overall business climate. Idaho has an income tax, but their tax system has been far more stable than Washington’s. Their Legislature isn’t proposing billions in new taxes literally every year like we’ve experienced here in Washington.
Will businesses really leave? Some have already gone. With technology, it’s easier than ever to live in one state and own a business in another state.
Others are putting plans in motion now that won’t be completed for a few years. Keep in mind that moving to another state, whether it’s a family or business, is a big decision that can take years to achieve.
And still others may never leave, but they’re looking to grow in other states rather than here in Washington. This means fewer new jobs in our communities, less capital investment and slower wage growth.
In the final few days of this legislative session, lawmakers should carefully consider how their decisions will impact the state economy and whether their votes will help or hurt small- and medium-sized business owners who are already feeling pessimistic.
Employers are wary of the tax debate that’s happening right now in Olympia because it seems focused on how to bring in more money for the state (even though state revenue has doubled in the last decade).
Yes, the bills being discussed include some tax relief measures for families and small businesses, but those measures feel tacked on as something of an afterthought. The real sense of urgency is about how to bring in more money, not how to compete with some of these states that are looking increasingly attractive to Washington businesses.
Asking whether businesses will really leave is the wrong question. This isn’t a time for lawmakers to play chicken with the economy.
A better question is, what can lawmakers do to grow the economy? What’s their plan for supporting businesses, boosting competitiveness and strengthening the economy in every part of Washington?
The Association of Washington Business employer survey can be viewed at www.bit.ly/AWBEmployerSurvey
Kris Johnson is president of the Association of Washington Business, the state’s chamber of commerce and manufacturers association.